Kooperativer Bibliotheksverbund

UID:

Format: 235 Seiten , 22.7 cm x 15.3 cm

Edition: 1st edition

ISBN: 9783848763771 , 9781509936830 , 384876377X

Series Statement: Studien zur Strafrechtstheorie und Strafrechtsethik volume 4

Language: English

Subjects: Law

Keywords: Deutschland ; Skandinavien ; Italien ; Japan ; China ; Rechtsrealismus ; Strafrechtstheorie ; Rechtswissenschaft ; Wissenschaftlichkeit ; Aufsatzsammlung ; Aufsatzsammlung

URL: Inhaltstext

URL: Inhaltsverzeichnis

URL: Inhaltstext

URL: Inhaltsverzeichnis

Author information: Matsuzawa, Shin 1968-

UID:

Format: 1 Online-Ressource (235 Seiten)

Edition: 1st edition

ISBN: 9783748904755

Series Statement: Studien zur Strafrechtstheorie und Strafrechtsethik volume 4

Content: In dem Band wird erörtert, ob die Strafrechtstheorie (bzw. die allgemeine Rechtstheorie) als ein Zweig der Wissenschaft angesehen werden kann. Dabei werden folgende Fragen behandelt: In welchem Sinne ist die Strafrechtslehre eine Form der Wissenschaft? Kann es systemische Entwicklungen in der Strafrechtstheorie geben? Die Frage nach dem Wesen der strafrechtlichen Erkenntnis ist eng verknüpft mit der Frage, was Rechtswissenschaft im Allgemeinen ausmacht. Eine Diskussion im Bereich des Strafrechts kann einen Beitrag zur allgemeinen Diskussion in der Rechtstheorie leisten und deutlich machen, wo die Strafrechtstheorie steht, wenn die juristische Forschung mit den Herausforderungen der Interdisziplinarität konfrontiert wird. Mit Beiträgen von Petter Asp, Thomas Elholm, Liang Genlin, Luís Greco, Eric Hilgendorf, Jørn Jacobsen, Heike Jung, Massimiliano Lanzi, Shin Matsuzawa, Kimmo Nuotio und Michael Pawlik.

Content: This book discusses whether criminal law theory, or in more general terms, general law theory can be regarded as a branch of science. The issues addressed in this book are following: Is the criminal law scholarship which obviously informs the legal system itself a form of science, and in what sense? Can there be systemic developments in criminal law theory? The issues concerning the nature of the knowledge of criminal law in the core areas of the field are of course closely linked with issues concerning what legal science is more generally about. A reflective discussion in the field of criminal law on these issues may contribute to the general discussions in legal theory, and also it serves the interest of understanding where criminal law theory stands when legal research is increasingly faced with challenges of interdisciplinarity. With contributions by Petter Asp, Thomas Elholm, Liang Genlin, Luís Greco, Eric Hilgendorf, Jørn Jacobsen, Heike Jung, Massimiliano Lanzi, Shin Matsuzawa, Kimmo Nuotio and Michael Pawlik.

Note: Gesehen am 13.07.2021

Additional Edition: ISBN 9783848763771

Additional Edition: ISBN 9781509936830

Additional Edition: Erscheint auch als Druck-Ausgabe Methodology of criminal law theory: art, politics or science? Baden-Baden : Nomos, 2021 ISBN 9783848763771

Additional Edition: ISBN 9781509936830

Additional Edition: ISBN 384876377X

Language: English

Subjects: Law

Keywords: Deutschland ; Skandinavien ; Italien ; Japan ; China ; Rechtsrealismus ; Strafrechtstheorie ; Rechtswissenschaft ; Wissenschaftlichkeit ; Aufsatzsammlung

DOI: 10.5771/9783748904755

URL: Volltext  (lizenzpflichtig)

URL: Volltext  (lizenzpflichtig)

URL: Volltext  (lizenzpflichtig)

URL: Inhaltstext

URL: Inhaltsverzeichnis

Author information: Matsuzawa, Shin 1968-

UID:

Format: 1 Online-Ressource (236 Seiten)

Edition: 1st ed

ISBN: 9783748904755

Series Statement: Studien zur Strafrechtstheorie und Strafrechtsethik v.4

Note: Description based on publisher supplied metadata and other sources , Cover -- The Methods of Legal Dogmatics of Criminal Law From a Realistic Perspective -- I. Foreword -- II. What is Legal Dogmatics of Criminal Law? -- 1. Characteristics of Legal Dogmatics of Criminal Law in Germany -- 2. Characteristics of legal dogmatics of criminal law in Japan -- 3. Appropriateness of normative construction of legal dogmatics of criminal law -- 4. Orientation towards a more scientific dogmatic of criminal law -- III. Methodologies for Scientific Dogmatic of Criminal Law -- 1. Pre-War: Positivism -- 2. Post-War: Empirical studies of law -- 3. Orientation towards science in legal philosophy (science of legal studies): Scandinavian case -- (1) Introduction -- (2) Scandinavian legal realism -- (i) Uppsala school -- (ii) Alf Ross -- 4. Ross theory as applied by Waaben -- (1) Ross theory: The concept of valid law and prediction theory -- (2) Method of conceptual structure by Waaben: Criticism of German methodology -- (3) Application by the author -- IV. Criticism of the Methodology/Issues and Review -- 1. Introduction -- 2. Is valid law only applicable to thought process of judges? -- 3. Can predictions be proven true or false? -- 4. Judges subjected to prediction react to the situation: Can there be science in such a relationship? -- 5. Distinction between legal dogmatics and legal politics -- 6. Would it not be an obstacle to nurturing students and jurists capable of external criticism? -- 7. What are the features of judges' thought process? -- 8. Conclusion -- V. Method for Dogmatic of Criminal Law: Methodology for extraction and structuring of theories -- 1. Methodology for extraction of theory -- 2. Method of theoretical structuring -- Ⅵ. Methods of Criminal Law Policies: Preliminary Observation -- 1. Foundation of legal politics of criminal law -- 2. Function of creation of law by judges and legal politics of criminal law , 3. On the definition of logic -- VII. Conclusion -- In Defence of a Normative and Non-Scientific Legal Science -- [Introduction] -- [Law is Janus-faced] -- [Rules and principles] -- [Constructing the law or just working with the materials] -- [Rules, principles and the actors of the legal system] -- [The system and its ability to determine what judges do] -- [The Meta-Norms on the Sources of Law adds to the Openness] -- [Concluding remarks] -- One Method, Two (Mandatory) Perspectives -- Introduction -- Highlighting the differences -- Alf Ross and the concept of valid law -- The separation between dogmatics and politics -- Asp vs Matsuzawa - do they agree in the end? -- Hypothesis 1: A normative approach can be equivalent to a study of the thought processes of judges -- Hypothesis 2: Value judgments are necessary for judges -- Hypothesis 3 - Both approaches are beneficial to society -- There is Nothing New under the Sun? -- Conclusion -- Criminal Law Scholarship - Should It Be Able to Present Itself as Science? -- 1. The Finnish entrance point -- 2. Criminal law as a science -- 3. One step back towards a normative understanding of criminal law -- 4. Where to go next? -- How Can Legal Doctrine be a Scientific Discipline? Methodological Groundworks for the Norwegian Criminal Law Doctrine -- 1 Introduction -- 2 Aim and Actuality -- 3 Starting Point: The Concept of Science -- 4 Engaging the Concept of Law -- 5 More on Legal Doctrine' Justification Challenge -- 6 Solving the Justification challenge -- 7 Epilogue: No Farewell to Criminal Law Doctrine -- The method of (German) criminal law dogmatics -- I. The undertaking at issue -- II. Sublime German theory? Or: German criminal law scholarship, seen from within -- III. Exemplification: Foundation and limits of the justification of aggressive necessity. Or: A German criminal law essay, seen from within , IV. Conclusion -- Law and Science -- Naturalism in Law and Philosophy -- Historical Links between Law and Science -- Values and Norms -- Questions of Value in Law -- Sociobiological Reasoning in Law? -- An Interest-Oriented Concept of Value Foundation -- Naturalism in Legal Doctrine -- In order to review the possibility of transferring naturalistic thinking into law, it is not sufficient to simply consider questions of values and norms, for that is an issue of legal philosophy rather than of law itself. In this section, I discuss the possibility of interpreting practical legal concepts in a way compatible with the naturalistic program. -- Human Dignity -- Causation -- Legal Method and Naturalism -- Statutory Interpretation -- The Application of Law -- Conclusion -- References -- Rechtswissenschaft revisited -- I. Why this topic? -- II. From "art" to science (?): a few glimpses of history -- III. Making sense of "legal science" -- IV. Some practical consequences -- V. Conclusion -- Criminal Law Science: from Legal Technicism to Postmodern Legality. An Italian perspective. -- 0. Introduction. -- 1. Just a matter of definition... or isn't? -- 2. The success of the scientific method in Criminal Law Science. -- 3. A new puzzle of sources for the Criminal Law. -- 4. From objectiveness to case-by-case justice. -- 5. The approach of Criminal Law Science to the new legality model. -- Transformation of criminal law science in China: Description and Discussion -- Introduction -- I. Learning from Soviet Union: Main Points of the "Four Constituents" Theory of Crime Construction -- II. Following the Example of Germany and Japan: Introduction of the Step-Up Level Theory and the Doctrine of "Reconstruction" -- 1. Construction of Three-Layered Structure of Crime of Professor Chen Xingliang , 2. Construction of Two-Layered Structure of Crime of Professor Zhang Mingkai -- III. Preservation and Improvement of the "Four Constituents" Theory -- IV. The Doctrine of Modification Between Preservation and Reconstruction -- V. Discussion on transformation of criminal law science in China -- 1. Ambiguity of the Step-Up Level Theory as Reference Model -- 2. Preference for Theory Restricted by the Educational Background of Scholars -- 3. Influence of Personal Value Concept and Individualized Research Style of Scholars -- 4. Lack of Thorough Understanding of German and Japanese Criminal Law Theories -- 5. Lack of Adjustment to Theory and Practice in China -- The Role of Philosophy within the General Theory of Crime -- I. The Autonomy of Legal Discourse and Its Limits -- II. Is the General Theory of Crime a Scientific Discipline? -- III. The Affinity of the General Theory of Crime with Philosophy -- IV. A Glance Back at the History of Ideas (1): The Self-Conception and Practice of the General Theory of Crime -- V. A Glance Back at the History of Ideas (2): The Contribution of Philosophy to the General Theory of Crime -- VI. The Task of Today's General Theory of Crime -- List of Contributors

Additional Edition: Erscheint auch als Druck-Ausgabe Matsuzawa, Shin Methodology of Criminal Law Theory: Art, Politics or Science? Baden-Baden : Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft,c2021 ISBN 9783848763771

Language: English

Subjects: Law

Keywords: Deutschland ; Skandinavien ; Italien ; Japan ; China ; Rechtsrealismus ; Strafrechtstheorie ; Rechtswissenschaft ; Wissenschaftlichkeit ; Aufsatzsammlung