Format:
1 Online-Ressource (300 pages)
ISBN:
9781108668354
Series Statement:
Cambridge Studies in International and Comparative Law v.138
Content:
Discusses how an analogy between States and international organizations has influenced the development of international law
Content:
Cover -- Half-title -- Series information -- Title page -- Copyright information -- Dedication -- Contents -- Foreword -- Acknowledgements -- Table of Cases -- International Court of Justice -- Permanent Court of International Justice -- Court of Justice of the European Union -- European Court of Human Rights -- International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea -- International Criminal Tribunals -- World Trade Organization -- Arbitral Awards -- Domestic Courts -- Germany -- Italy -- Netherlands -- Switzerland -- United Kingdom -- United States -- Select Table of Key Documents -- List of Abbreviations -- Introduction -- Terminological Clarifications -- Structure of the Book -- Part I The Case for an Analogy -- 1 Analogy in International Legal Reasoning -- 1.1 The Normative Case for Analogy in Legal Reasoning -- 1.1.1 A Jurisprudential Divide -- 1.1.2 The Structure of Analogical Reasoning -- 1.1.3 Systematicity, Formal Justice and the Rule of Law -- 1.1.4 Challenging Analogies -- 1.2 Analogy in International Legal Reasoning -- 1.2.1 The Systematicity of International Law -- 1.2.2 Completeness of the System and the Lotus Closure Rule -- 1.3 Analogy in the Codification and Progressive Development of International Law -- 1.3.1 Systemic Codification by Analogy -- 1.3.2 Analogy as a Method in the Projects on Treaties and Responsibility of IOs -- 1.3.3 The Ripeness Objection -- 1.4 Concluding Remarks -- 2 The Foundations of the Analogy between States and International Organizations -- 2.1 International Organizations as a Category of International Legal Subjects -- 2.1.1 Two Conceptions of the Status of International Organizations -- 2.1.1.1 The Two Conceptions in the Work of the ILC -- 2.1.1.2 Weighing the Conceptions -- 2.1.1.3 The Importance of Taking a Position -- 2.1.2 In Search of a Unifying Principle
Content:
2.1.2.1 Attempts to Define 'International Organization' -- 2.1.2.2 International Legal Personality as a Unifying Principle? -- 2.1.2.3 International Legal Autonomy as a Unifying Principle -- 2.2 The Relevant Similarity between States and International Organizations -- 2.2.1 Legal Autonomy and the Capacity to Operate on the International Plane -- 2.2.2 Justifying the Relevant Similarity -- 2.3 Concluding Remarks -- Part II Objections to the Analogy -- 3 Structural Differences between States and International Organizations -- 3.1 'International Organizations Have No Territory' -- 3.2 'International Organizations Have No Population' -- 3.3 'International Organizations Have No Centralised Government' -- 3.3.1 Representation and Attribution of Conduct -- 3.3.2 Silence and the Acquisition and Loss of Rights -- 3.4 Assessing the Significance of Structural Differences -- 4 International Organizations as 'Special Subjects' -- 4.1 Different Rules for Different International Organizations? -- 4.1.1 Universal and Regional Organizations -- 4.1.2 Regional Integration Organizations -- 4.1.3 The Challenge of Establishing Subcategories -- 4.2 International Organizations as 'Derivative Subjects' of International Law -- 4.2.1 International Organizations and the Formation of Custom -- 4.2.2 International Organizations and the Formation of Peremptory Norms -- 4.2.3 International Organizations and Law-Making Treaties -- 4.3 International Organizations as Subjects with Limited Competence -- 4.3.1 The Case for a Wide-Reaching Principle of Speciality -- 4.3.2 Speciality and the Observance and Invalidity of Treaties -- 4.3.3 Speciality and Responsibility for Ultra Vires Conduct -- 4.3.4 The Proper Scope of the Principle of Speciality -- 4.3.5 The Principle of Speciality, Lex Specialis and the Relevance of General Rules -- 4.4 Concluding Remarks
Content:
5 International Organizations as 'Layered Subjects' -- 5.1 The Push towards an Analogy between Unitary and Layered Subjects -- 5.1.1 International Organizations and the Relative Effect of Treaties -- 5.1.2 International Organizations and the Principle of Independent Responsibility -- 5.1.2.1 Rules on Attribution of Conduct -- 5.1.2.2 Rules on Attribution of Responsibility -- 5.2 Calibrating the Analogy between Unitary and Layered Subjects -- 5.2.1 Acceptance of Rights, Obligations and Responsibility -- 5.2.1.1 Acceptance of Rights and Obligations by Member States -- 5.2.1.2 Acceptance of Rights and Obligations by Organizations -- 5.2.1.3 Acceptance of Responsibility by Member States -- 5.2.2 Responsibility for Circumvention of International Obligations -- 5.2.2.1 Legal Character and Systemic Function of Provisions on Circumvention -- 5.2.2.2 The Limits of Provisions on Circumvention -- 5.2.3 Enabling Organizations to Perform their International Obligations -- 5.3 Concluding Remarks -- Part III Limits of the Analogy -- 6 Analogy in the Relations between Organizations and Members -- 6.1 Relations on the International Plane -- 6.1.1 General International Law as the Applicable Law -- 6.1.2 The Rules of the Organization as Lex Specialis -- 6.1.3 Membership Ties and Obligations of Cooperation -- 6.2 Relations on the Institutional Plane -- 6.2.1 The Analogy's Breaking Point -- 6.2.2 The Terms of the Relations between International Legal Orders -- 6.2.2.1 A Monistic Presumption? -- 6.2.2.2 Limits of the Monistic Presumption -- 6.3 Concluding Remarks -- 7 Normative Contestation of the Analogy -- 7.1 Contestation in the Application of 'Primary Rules' to International Organizations -- 7.1.1 Law of Immunities -- 7.1.2 Law of Armed Conflict -- 7.2 Contestation in the Application of 'Secondary Rules' to International Organizations -- 7.2.1 Reservations to Treaties
Content:
7.2.2 Countermeasures -- 7.2.3 Necessity -- 7.2.4 Invocation of Responsibility by an 'Interested Organization' -- 7.3 Concluding Remarks -- Conclusion -- Drawing the Threads Together -- Analogy, the ILC and the Future of the Law of International Organizations -- Bibliography -- Index
Additional Edition:
ISBN 9781107155558
Additional Edition:
Print version Bordin, Fernando Lusa The Analogy between States and International Organizations Cambridge : Cambridge University Press,c2018 ISBN 9781107155558
Language:
English
Bookmarklink
