Your email was sent successfully. Check your inbox.

An error occurred while sending the email. Please try again.

Proceed reservation?

Export
Filter
  • Brill  (2)
Type of Medium
Publisher
  • Brill  (2)
Person/Organisation
Language
Years
  • 1
    Online Resource
    Online Resource
    Brill ; 2011
    In:  Israel Journal of Ecology and Evolution Vol. 57, No. 3 ( 2011-05-6), p. 207-211
    In: Israel Journal of Ecology and Evolution, Brill, Vol. 57, No. 3 ( 2011-05-6), p. 207-211
    Abstract: In their rebuttal to my comment, Roll et al. (2011) defend their original conclusion, by questioning the theoretical framework on which I based my analysis. They stress the importance of the statistical prediction limits and the treatment of latitudinal location as a covariate. They also add an additional grid-cell-based analysis. Here, I claim that even if provincial species-area relationships (SPAR) are not parallel, they are still different. While relying on Roll et al.'s (2011) analyses, I show that for each taxon there is at least one other provincial SPAR that lies considerably above the Palaearctic SPAR, making Palaearctic countries less favorable to be identified as a global biodiversity hotspot. I further claim that prediction limits should not be used to answer the question in focus and that adding latitude as a covariate does not alter the results. Finally, I address the grid-cell analyses of Roll et al. (2011), claiming that Israel's diversity lies mainly in the species turnover between cells (i.e., β diversity) and not on the average species richness within cells (α diversity). Therefore I hold on to my former conclusion that at least for three taxa—birds, mammals, and reptiles—Israel is indeed a Palaearctic provincial hotspot.
    Type of Medium: Online Resource
    ISSN: 1565-9801 , 2224-4662
    Language: Unknown
    Publisher: Brill
    Publication Date: 2011
    SSG: 12
    Library Location Call Number Volume/Issue/Year Availability
    BibTip Others were also interested in ...
  • 2
    Online Resource
    Online Resource
    Brill ; 2011
    In:  Israel Journal of Ecology and Evolution Vol. 57, No. 3 ( 2011-05-6), p. 183-192
    In: Israel Journal of Ecology and Evolution, Brill, Vol. 57, No. 3 ( 2011-05-6), p. 183-192
    Abstract: Each evolutionary-independent province has its own mainland species area relationship (SPAR). When using the power law SPAR (S = cA z ), separate mainland SPARs are parallel in a log-log space (similar z value), yet they differ in species density per unit area (c value). This implies that there are two main SPAR-based strategies to identify biodiversity hotspots. The first treats all mainland SPARs of all provinces as if they form one global SPAR. This is the strategy employed by Roll et al. (2009) when questioning Israel's high biodiversity. They concluded that Israel is not a global biodiversity hotspot. Their results may arise from the fact that Israel's province, the Palaearctic, is relatively poor. Therefore, countries from richer provinces, whose mainland SPAR lies above the Palaearctic SPAR, are identified as global hotspots. The second strategy is to construct different mainland SPARs for each province and identify the provincial hotspots. In this manuscript I ask whether Israel's biodiversity is high relative to other countries within its province. For six different taxa, I analyzed data for Palaearctic countries. For each taxon, I conducted a linear regression of species richness against the country's area, both log transformed. The studentized residuals were used to explore Israel's rank relative to all other Palaearctic countries. I found that Israel lies above the 95th percentile for reptiles and mammals and above the 90th percentile for birds. Therefore, within the Palaearctic province, Israel is indeed a biodiversity hotspot.
    Type of Medium: Online Resource
    ISSN: 1565-9801 , 2224-4662
    Language: Unknown
    Publisher: Brill
    Publication Date: 2011
    SSG: 12
    Library Location Call Number Volume/Issue/Year Availability
    BibTip Others were also interested in ...
Close ⊗
This website uses cookies and the analysis tool Matomo. Further information can be found on the KOBV privacy pages