Elsevier

Geoderma

Volume 346, 15 July 2019, Pages 52-62
Geoderma

Computed tomography as an extension of classical methods in the analysis of soil compaction, exemplified on samples from two tillage treatments and at two moisture tensions

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geoderma.2019.03.023Get rights and content

Highlights

  • The CT parameters were all closely and uniquely related to each other.

  • The CT parameters can be used for a standardized characterization of the soil.

  • For cultivator water content was less effective in increasing already high soil stability.

  • Positive effect of plough as long as macroporosity and pore connectivity remains high.

  • Plough maintains higher pore connectivity when compacted under dry conditions.

Abstract

Some soil physical properties can easily be measured using classical laboratory methods. However, explicit valuable information on the real morphology of the pore structure as well as soil physical properties cannot be obtained at the same time with classical methods. This requires non-destructive measurements such as X-ray computed tomography (CT).

However, explicit valuable information on the real morphology of the pore structure as well as soil physical properties cannot be obtained at the same time with classical methods.

This paper combines parameters obtained from CT analysis (mean macropore diameter, macroporosity, pore connectivity, anisotropy) and classical laboratory methods (dry bulk and aggregate density, saturated hydraulic conductivity, mechanical precompression stress) to analyse soil compaction, exemplified on samples from two tillage treatments (cultivator and plough) and at two moisture states (6 and 1000 kPa matric potential) on a Chernozem collected at a soil depth of 16–22 cm (texture 0–30 cm: silty clay loam).

The study shows that the matric potential can have a decisive impact on the mechanical stability of soil. In the loose but less stable plough treatment a more negative matric potential was clearly beneficial to the mechanical stability. In already dense soil structures, as in the cultivator treatment, a reduction of water content was less effective in increasing soil stability.

The CT parameters were all closely and uniquely related to each other. The shown CT parameters can be used for a standardized characterization of the soil. Ploughing has a positive effect on soil structure which persists only as long as macroporosity and mean macropore diameter remain high. Plough maintains higher pore connectivity when compacted under dry conditions.

Introduction

Soil physical properties such as dry bulk density, aggregate stability or water retention offer valuable information on pore morphology and can easily be measured using classical laboratory methods. However, explicit information about soil structure changes cannot be obtained with classical methods non-destructively. This requires non-destructive measurements such as X-ray computed tomography (CT), a non-invasive 3D imaging technique. This allows to analyse the morphology of the soil pore system at a given resolution in great detail (Keller et al., 2013; Pöhlitz et al., 2018; Rabot et al., 2018; Schlüter et al., 2018).

A promising application is to investigate structural changes induced by soil compaction in agricultural soils which is associated with different tillage systems and different soil moisture regimes. Soil compaction causes serious environmental and agricultural problems, e.g. soil erosion and flooding due to increased runoff, water quality problems due to the deposition of eroded material in water bodies, and yield reductions due to the loss of fertile topsoil and the restriction of root growth. More directly, compaction has a negative impact on soil aeration and the water balance. The primary cause of soil compaction is the repeated application of heavy loads on the field in the process of agronomic operations such as tillage, seeding, fertilization, crop protection and harvest.

The task of soil tillage is to support crop development by improving gas exchange and the water balance. There is an increasing focus on conservation-oriented soil tillage techniques (e.g. Amin et al., 2014; Dal Ferro et al., 2014) and the risk of damaging soil structure can be minimized (Koch et al., 2008; Rücknagel et al., 2012a). For example, farmers can combine individual working steps to reduce the number of times the field is driven over (Pagliai et al., 1983). At the same time it is necessary to consider that soil compaction of conservation-oriented tillage especially no tillage systems is more crucial to restrict soil functions.

Differences in soil tillage practices are mainly reflected in structural attributes of the topsoil. Physical soil properties such as dry bulk density, aggregate stability or pore size distribution are directly influenced by mechanical disturbances during tillage (FAO, 1993), and by driving over the ground (Carter, 2004). The change in physical properties is associated with changes in the morphology of the pore system which can affect the air, heat and water balance to varying degrees (e.g. Imhoff et al., 2004; Pagliai and Jones, 2002; Saffih-Hdadi et al., 2009).

Mechanical stability of soil is highly sensitive to soil moisture (Rücknagel et al., 2012b). This is well known and has been studied intensely. Soil moisture is not only subject to seasonal fluctuations, but also affected by soil tillage and crop type (Khan et al., 1999; Mackie-Dawson et al., 1989). Thus, even well suited soil tillage systems can massively damage soil structure depending on the actual conditions in terms of soil moisture. Many previous studies have extensively dealt with the effect of different tillage systems on soil compaction (e.g. Dal Ferro et al., 2014; Jarvis et al., 2017), with the interactions between mechanical precompression stress, dry bulk density and water content (e.g. Alexandrou and Earl, 1998), and with models and predictions of mechanical precompression stress for different water content values (e.g. Rücknagel et al., 2012b; Saffih-Hdadi et al., 2009).

In this paper we investigate what can be gained, if computed tomography is used in conjunction with classical methods to describe soil compaction. To do so, the effects of increasing stress on soil samples from two tillage treatments (cultivator and plough) and at two moisture regimes (6 and 1000 kPa) were investigated by looking at classical physical and mechanical soil properties, as well as at the pore structure examined with X-ray CT.

We are well aware that the relationship between compaction, water content and tillage, respectively, has already been extensively researched. Our motivation is to explore the added value of 3D imaging for understanding the pore scale processes during compaction for the different tillage systems and moisture regimes.

Section snippets

Trial site

The site is located near Buttelstedt (Germany, federal state of Thuringia, 11° 20′ O, 51° 4′ N; 200 m above sea level), where a tillage trial was established in 2008. The average annual temperature is 8.4 °C, the average annual precipitation amounts to 541 mm and the average annual evapotranspiration to 641 mm. The soil type is a Chernozem (FAO, 1998), the texture of the topsoil (0–30 cm) is silty clay loam (USDA, 1997) with 293 g kg−1 clay, 662 g kg−1 silt and 45 g kg−1 sand. The total organic

Initial soil physical conditions

As one would expect from the research cited in the introduction, the plough treatment initially had a lower BD (1.19 g cm−3) and a higher saturated conductivity (530.3 cm d−1) compared to the cultivator treatment (1.48 g cm−3, 47.9 cm d−1). The gravimetric water content was significantly higher for ‘plough’ than ‘cultivator’ at −6 kPa. However, at −1000 kPa matric potential the water content did not differ significantly between the samples taken for the two load step application methods (Table 1

Effects of tillage treatment and matric potential on compaction

Our study confirms older work on the influence of tillage and soil moisture on mechanical stability (e.g. Imhoff et al., 2004; Saffih-Hdadi et al., 2009), namely a mechanically more stable soil structure under cultivator compared to plough. There was a disproportionately high increase in mechanical stability in the ploughed soil for a dry soil moisture regime. This increase was found to a much lesser extent in the cultivator treatment.

Aggregates have a much larger recompression range and

Conclusions

With X-ray tomography (CT) it was possible to directly analyse the morphology of soil structure during compaction. In contrast to classical parameters, by using CT, a disturbance of the soil during the measuring process is reduced. The shown CT parameters can be used for a standardized characterization of the soil. Hence, CT provides a more complete picture of the compaction effects.

The combination of CT analysis with classical soil mechanical measurement provided a consistent interpretation

Acknowledgments

Many thanks to K. Marschall from the “Thüringer Landesanstalt für Landwirtschaft” and S. Reimann from the “Thüringer Lehr-, Prüf- und Versuchsgut GmbH” for the permission to take soil samples at their experimental site in Buttelstedt. Also, the expert technical assistance and guidance of J. M. Köhne when it came to CT image acquisition is gratefully acknowledged.

References (46)

  • E. Rabot et al.

    Soil structure as an indicator of soil functions: a review

    Geoderma

    (2018)
  • P. Renard et al.

    Connectivity metrics for subsurface flow and transport

    Adv. Water Res.

    (2013)
  • J. Rücknagel et al.

    Estimating pre-compression stress of structured soils on the basis of aggregate density and dry bulk density

    Soil Till. Res.

    (2007)
  • J. Rücknagel et al.

    Variance of mechanical precompression stress in graphic estimations using the Casagrande method and derived mathematical models

    Soil Till. Res.

    (2010)
  • J. Rücknagel et al.

    Impact on soil compaction of driving agricultural machinery over ground frozen near the surface

    Cold Reg. Sci. Technol.

    (2012)
  • J. Rücknagel et al.

    The influence of soil gravel content on compaction behaviour and pre-compression stress

    Geoderma

    (2013)
  • K. Saffih-Hdadi et al.

    A method for predicting soil susceptibility to the compaction of surface layers as a function of water content and bulk density

    Soil Till. Res.

    (2009)
  • S. Schlüter et al.

    Long-term effects of conventional and reduced tillage on soil structure, soil ecological and soil hydraulic properties

    Geoderma

    (2018)
  • D. Wildenschild et al.

    X-ray imaging and analysis techniques for quantifying pore-scale structure and processes in subsurface porous medium systems

    Adv. Water Resour.

    (2013)
  • M. Amin et al.

    Effect of different tillage practices on soil physical properties under wheat in semi-arid environment

    Soil Environ

    (2014)
  • G.R. Blake et al.

    Bulk density

  • J.M. Bradford et al.

    Compressibility

  • A. Buades et al.

    A review of image denoising algorithms, with a new one

    Multiscale Model. Simul.

    (2005)
  • Cited by (23)

    • Does the duration of no-till implementation influence depth distribution of soil organic carbon, hydro-physical properties, and computed tomography-derived macropore characteristics?

      2022, Soil and Tillage Research
      Citation Excerpt :

      However, several definitions of macropores followed in the literature might be the reason for obtaining contrasting results. For example, Pöhlitz et al. (2019) considered pores with ECD of > 60 µm as macropores, whereas, da Silva et al. (2021) considered pores with ECD of > 120 µm for large samples and > 74 µm for small samples as macropores. In this study, macropores were considered to have an ECD > 500-µm and LTNT resulted in a significant improvement as compared to the CT.

    • Long-term no tillage management impact on soil hydro-physical properties in coffee cultivation

      2021, Geoderma
      Citation Excerpt :

      However, some short-term studies investigating MT and NT have reported an increase in bulk density values, commonly resulting in poor soil structure and restriction of root growth and water movement in the untilled topsoil (Ball and Robertson, 1994; Morris et al., 2010; Munkholm et al., 2013). In contrast, most long-term studies on these managements posited that the soil structure improves over time in MT and NT fields (Ajayi and Horn, 2016; Rodrigues et al., 2016; Miguel et al., 2016; Ajayi et al., 2019; Schlüter et al., 2018; Pöhlitz et al., 2019). Consequently, soil functions that support crop growth are improved, and the potential to sequestrate carbon in the soil under long term MT and NT is also enhanced.

    • Can Lumbricus terrestris be released in forest soils degraded by compaction? Preliminary results from laboratory and field experiments

      2021, Applied Soil Ecology
      Citation Excerpt :

      However our findings were comparable with those of Pöhlitz et al. (2020) who showed that, for silt loam soils, the number of biopores produced by L. terrestris decreased between 1.35 and 1.6 g cm−3 with about 30% less biopores at 1.6 g cm−3 (albeit this decrease was not significant). Moreover, the relationships between biopore number and BD were not linear (cf Fig. 5C in Pöhlitz et al., 2020), which is in agreement with our findings, also in a silt loam soil. It appeared that for the earthworm species L. terrestris, there is a threshold effect.

    • Decreased burrowing activity of endogeic earthworms and effects on water infiltration in response to an increase in soil bulk density

      2021, Pedobiologia
      Citation Excerpt :

      This kind of study provides information on earthworm preferences but not really on their ability to burrow and live in compacted soils. Furthermore, in most studies only two to three BD were tested (Joschko et al., 1989, 1993; Langmaack et al., 1999; Stovold et al., 2004; Jégou et al., 2002; Capowiez et al., 2012) whereas recent studies suggested that depending on the soil texture, earthworm responses in terms of burrowing are not always monotonic (see Fig. 5 in Pöhlitz et al., 2020). Overall, there is an increasing demand for accurate estimates of the effects of BD on earthworm burrowing (Roeben et al., 2020) since this kind of information is required, for example, to simulate earthworm behavior and better assess their real exposure to pesticides.

    View all citing articles on Scopus
    View full text