We describe a method for the analysis of the distribution of displacements, i.e., the propagators, of single-particle tracking measurements for the case of obstructed subdiffusion in two-dimensional membranes. The propagator for the percolation cluster is compared with a two-component mobility model against Monte Carlo simulations. To account for diffusion in the presence of obstacle concentrations below the percolation threshold, a propagator that includes the transient motion in finite percolation clusters and hopping between obstacle-induced compartments is derived. Finally, these models are shown to be effective in the analysis of Kv2.1 channel diffusive measurements in the membrane of living mammalian cells.